What is this thing against software?

 
rob
Member
Avatar
Gender: n/a
Location: h
Homepage: robdikken.nl
Posts: 144
Registered: 02 / 2007
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 03.08.2007 - 23:13  ·  #9
my ears?

They're also software!
Guestuser
 
Avatar
 
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 03.08.2007 - 23:46  ·  #10
I only use Software for recording and mastering and that's it.
MarkM
Member
Avatar
Gender: n/a
Location: East Tennessee
Homepage: reverbnation.com/m…
Posts: 77
Registered: 07 / 2007
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 04.08.2007 - 03:12  ·  #11
More bang for the buck? That's not always the case. My favorite soft synth is Reaktor. Everytime it upgrades, I pay for it. Eventually, I'll upgrade to a new OS on my computer (not anytime soon), and I'll have to upgrade all my softsynths as well. And ofcourse there's the cost of Midi/usb adaptors, better sound cards, and a decent midi controller. I'd say I've invested about $1000 since I bought Reaktor 3. I doubt I will ever see any of that investment returned if I thought about selling it.

As far as crashing: fortunately I have never had that happen while performing with my soft synths. But I have had my Q rack go out on me, and it was my laptop that filled in for the out-of-commission hardware.

I like soft synths. Some, like Reaktor, have designs that go beyond what any hardware synth can do. I wish some companies would avoid trying to emulate old analogue classics and use their imaginations to come up with insane designs that will inspire the adventuresome musician.

I don't think there is much difference between a soft synth and a VA. Perhaps the VA is less likely to crash (with the exception of my fore mentioned Q) since its OS is not boggled down with non-musical functions. They're both mavelously digital, and I like that sound. I have two analogue synths, but I wonder how analogue they sound after I process the hell out of the audio with my Lexicon and EchoPro.

Like others have stated; all that matters is the music.

Last year while attending a class for my masters in teaching, we had a related arts class. The assignment was to make a musical instrument. Most of my fellow students created some sort of percussion instrument, like a shaker or rattle. I took a Tide detergent box, cut a hole, and had rubber bands criss-cross over the opening. I then took a contact pickup, a digital delay, and a small practice amp and presented it to the class. It had a great sound: very ambient! I guess the point I'm trying to make is that if it makes a sound, then you have the potential to make music. Soft synth. . . VA . . . Moog modular. . .comb . . .it doesn't matter. Each has its own wonderful qualities.
Guestuser
 
Avatar
 
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 04.08.2007 - 10:40  ·  #12
I definitely not against software based instruments in using them. The big minus for me is that because they're hidden on my Apple, I tend to forget using them. And buying stuff for forgetting is expensive.

In the past I had lots of equipment (14-18 synths). Nowadays I don't want that anymore. 8-10 is maximum. Not of the space, but for not to kill creativity.
ambientlive
Member
Avatar
Gender: n/a
Location: Boston/Swindon UK
Homepage: ambientlive.com
Posts: 987
Registered: 02 / 2007
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 04.08.2007 - 14:22  ·  #13
I've used soft and hard synths on stage for many years.
The only time anything 'crashed' was when, due to being sited
in front of a car-sized subwoofer, the vibrations actually shook
the 'kettle' lead out of the back.
create
Member
Avatar
Gender: n/a
Homepage: create-em.co.uk
Posts: 321
Registered: 02 / 2007
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 04.08.2007 - 22:21  ·  #14
Quote by stingray64
Peter, im not a musician, but i have a good ear. IMO, software, real gear, to me it doesnt matter, if its good music, why should it matter? some people are just plainly ****** retentive on certain things, consider this one of them. Steve Humphries of Create used or uses software synths, and he did a fabulous job especially his first cd which i was hooked on composed if im not mistaken all on software synths, he did a phenomenal job and holds up well to some of the better EM cds out there composed with real gear.


Thanks! :)

Yes my first two Cd's Reflections From The Inner Light and From Earth To Mars were recorded using Reason 2.0/2.5 which is software based.

I use hardware and software when recording.

For me i can enjoy music recorded using hardware or software or even a mixture of both.
Guestuser
 
Avatar
 
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 05.08.2007 - 00:05  ·  #15
Quote by create
For me i can enjoy music recorded using hardware or software or even a mixture of both.


That's right my son.
dlmorley
Member
Avatar
Gender: n/a
Homepage: davidmorley.com
Posts: 817
Registered: 07 / 2007
Subject:

Re: What is this thing against software?

 · 
Posted: 05.08.2007 - 23:03  ·  #16
No problem with either myself.

The power of a full on hardware modular is where I get my kicks and that hasn't come close in software.

I prefer working on hardware and don't really enjoy being in front of the computer that much. I get excited to sit behind a synth and get lost in making sequences/sounds/noises etc. It's fun. The computer is basically my 24 track. I also mix analogue as there I certainly hear a huge difference.
Might just be me though, but that's the only person I can hear for 8)

On the other hand, taking my iBook anywhere and being able to write is a huge positive.
Plus some soft synths do stuff that hardware can't. The combination is good.

Of course the best softsynth in the world through a budget soundcard that is playing back 24 tracks is not going to do any soft synth any favours..
It all depends what you want to do and how you use it.

Oh and just as many people with just software tell everyone it is as good as hardware. The argument certainly works both ways... It isn't just us hardware owners feeling superior. It's actually lots of the time people with software based systems starting arguments by saying "but why do you use that when the soft version is just as good?" :P
Selected quotes for multi-quoting:   0

Registered users in this topic

Currently no registered users in this section

The statistic shows who was online during the last 5 minutes. Updated every 90 seconds.